You are here

Nondestructive Evaluation (NDE) Sensors, Modeling, and Analysis

Description:

Scope Title:

Nondestructive Evaluation (NDE) for In-Space and Additively Manufactured Materials/Structures

Scope Description:

Nondestructive evaluation (NDE) is the use of nondestructive interrogating energy to determine the integrity of materials. NDE activities can also be considered nondestructive inspection (NDI) or nondestructive testing (NDT). Systems interrogated may be organic or inorganic, simple or complex, and may be structural or nonstructural.

Flight fracture-critical components used in NASA missions require inspection and often require adaptation of advanced NDE technologies in order to be applicable for flight.  Nondestructive integrity determination includes characterization of engineering properties, strain, stress, load verification, cracks, voids, inclusions, disbonds, delaminations, bonding, corrosion, erosion, constitutive components, volume fraction, orientation, impact damage, age, pressure, mass loss, mass gain, thinning, alignment, thermal diffusivity, emissivity, leaks, signature, contamination, elements, etc.

NASA’s NDE SBIR subtopic will address a wide variety of NDE disciplines with a focus on in-space inspection. This SBIR solicitation will focus on aerospace structures and materials systems, including (but not limited to) Inconel, titanium, aluminum, carbon fiber, Avcoat, Alumina Enhanced Thermal Barrier (AETB), Phenolic Impregnated Carbon Ablator (PICA), lunar regolith, and thermal blanket structures. Development efforts should target any set of these materials in common aerospace configurations, such as micrometeoroid and orbital debris (MMOD) shielding, truss structures, and stiffened structures. As NASA strives for longer duration space missions, these new tools need to be developed to support in-space manufacturing and assembly.

NDE Sensors and Data Analysis:

Technologies enabling the ability to perform automated inspections on large or complex structures are encouraged. Technologies should provide reliable rapid assessments of the location and extent of damage or defects. This includes systems that can help identify flaws such as cracks, as well as systems that can help locate and characterize leaks on the International Space Station (ISS) or Gateway. Methods are desired to perform inspections in areas with difficult access in pressurized habitable compartments and external environments for flight hardware. Many applications require the ability to see through assembled conductive and/or thermal insulating materials without contacting the surface.

Techniques that can dynamically and accurately determine position and orientation of the NDE sensor are needed to register NDE results to precise locations on the structure with little to no human intervention. Advanced processing and displays are needed to reduce the complexity of operation and interpretation for astronaut crews who need to make important assessments quickly. NDE inspection sensors are needed for potential use on free-flying inspection platforms. Integration of wireless systems with NDE may be of significant utility. It is strongly encouraged that proposals provide an explanation of how the proposed techniques and sensors will be applied to a complex structure. Examples of structural components include (but are not limited to) multiwall pressure vessels, batteries, tile, thermal blankets, micrometeoroid shielding, ISS radiators, or aerospace structural components, including the lunar Gateway.

Additionally, techniques for quantitative analysis of sensor data are desired. It is also considered highly desirable to develop tools for automating detection of material foreign object debris (FOD), such as lunar dust and/or defects, and evaluation of bondline and in-depth integrity for ablative materials, such as a heat shield. Typical internal void volume detection requirements for ablative materials are on the order of less than 6 mm, and bondline defect detection requirements are less than 25 mm. 

In-Space Inspection:

Technologies sought under this SBIR include those related to in-space NDE. This includes on-orbit NDE (e.g., ISS or Gateway) as well as NDE for future lunar, Mars, or other planetary missions. This could include new NDE tools for astronauts to use in a habitat or in the space environment (i.e., on an extravehicular activity (EVA)) or for automated inspection. Technologies may include fully functional NDE tools developed based on ground-use/laboratory equipment. Consideration will also be given to particularly promising technologies that may not provide turnkey operation but enable the advancement of future NDE inspection capabilities in space (i.e., enabling technologies). Fully functional NDE “tool” designs must address considerations related to size, mass, power, safety, environment, operation and/or automation, and data transfer related to their proposed application. For example, an NDE tool designed for ISS must ultimately be able to meet (after final development) ISS design requirements, launch mass/payload limitations, operational guidelines for crew, etc. If no specific application is outlined in the design, or if the proposal is for development of an enabling technology, then consideration must still be given to system size, mass, power, and data rate, to the extent that it makes the technology feasible within the next decade. To that end, consideration may be given to technology developments that are specifically focused on minimizing (or optimizing) these system parameters (e.g., low-mass, compact microfocus x-ray sources).  Other related topics of high interest for in-space NDE, related to exploration and geotechnical characterization, include field-portable solutions for ground-penetrating radar (GPR), acoustic/vibration-based measurements (seismography), and regolith/drill core sample analysis (e.g., to determine density, composition, ice content, etc.).

This solicitation is aimed at technologies for conventional NDE inspection of relevant components in space, meaning detection of commonly known defects in materials (cracks, pores, delamination, FOD, impact damage, etc.), rather than analytical tools aimed at determining chemistry, composition, or other properties of materials. Relevant components to be inspected may include (but are not limited to) spaceflight hardware, protective gear, core/rock samples, structural components, electronics/wiring, pressure vessels, thermal protection systems, etc. Of particular interest are technologies that advance the inspection of additively manufactured parts in space. These parts may be manufactured in an additive manufacturing (AM) cabinet system that fits in an ISS EXPRESS (EXpedite the PRocessing of Experiments for Space Station) rack, which results in parts on the scale of 6 in. AM technologies used in such a payload could include fused deposition modeling, bound metal deposition, wire arc AM, or other technologies using wire feedstock. Large-scale space structures may be manufactured or assembled in the space environment using AM techniques. Inspection technologies may involve x-ray technology (such as computed tomography), ultrasonic imaging, thermography, or any other NDE methods adapted for space use. NDE tools or enabling technologies that are compact, easy to carry (by astronauts), and work on low or accessible power will be considered.

NASA's NDE SBIR program is developing and implementing tools for future use on NASA's most critical missions. NDE requires development and constant improvement of tools, methods, instruments, and personnel. Development activities in the SBIR NDE program range from development of cutting-edge software to hardware prototype development. Development and deployment of these NDE systems with properly trained personnel is the goal of the NDE SBIR program for NASA's current and future missions.

Expected TRL or TRL Range at completion of the Project: 1 to 6

Primary Technology Taxonomy:

  • Level 1 08 Sensors and Instruments
  • Level 2 08.X Other Sensors and Instruments

Desired Deliverables of Phase I and Phase II:

  • Research
  • Analysis
  • Prototype
  • Hardware
  • Software

Desired Deliverables Description:

Phase I Deliverables:

For proposals focusing on NDE sensors: Lab prototype and feasibility study or software package, including applicable data or observation of a measurable phenomenon on which the prototype will be built.

For proposals focusing on NDE modeling: Feasibility study, including demonstration simulations and data interpretation algorithms, proving the proposed approach to develop a given product to a TRL of 2 to 4.

All Phase 1 proposals will include a proposed approach to develop a given methodology to a TRL of 2 to 4. All Phase I proposals will include minimum of short description for Phase II prototype/software. It will be highly favorable to include a description of how the Phase II prototype or methodology will be applied to structures.

Phase II Deliverables:

Working prototype or software of proposed product, along with full report of development, validation, and test results. Prototype or software of proposed product should be of TRL 5 to 6. Proposal should include plan of how to apply prototype or software on applicable structure or material system. Opportunities and plans should also be identified and summarized for potential commercialization.

State of the Art and Critical Gaps:

NASA and the SBIR program are preparing for the next phase of human deep space flight. As such, much of the materials, structures, and subsystem will have to be built or assembled in space. Quantitative and qualitative inspection of these components and structures will be critical to ensure safe spaceflight. Additionally, NDE sensors will be used to determine the health of structures as they age in space. Solicitations for assessing structural health of lunar habitats will also be considered.  

Relevance / Science Traceability:

Several missions could benefit from technology developed in the area of NDE. Currently, NASA is returning to manned spaceflight. The Artemis program's Orion spacecraft and Space Launch System have had inspection difficulties, and continued development and implementation of NDE tools will serve to keep our missions flying safely. Currently, Orion is using several techniques and prototypes that have been produced under the NDE SBIR topic. The Space Launch System is NASA’s next heavy-lift system, capable of sending hundreds of metric tons into orbit. Inspection of the various systems is ongoing and will continue to have challenges, such as verification of the friction stir weld on the fuel tanks. As NASA continues to push into deeper space, smart structures that are instrumented with structural health monitoring (SHM) systems can provide real-time mission-critical information on the status of the structure. NDE of spaceflight hardware and parts manufactured in space will be key enabling technologies for constant crew presence and long-duration missions.

References:

  • Burke, E. R.; Dehaven, S. L.; and Williams, P. A.: Device and Method of Scintillating Quantum Dots for Radiation Imaging. U.S. Patent 9,651,682, Issued May 16, 2017.
  • Burke, E. R.; and Waller, J.: NASA-ESA-JAXA Additive Manufacturing Trilateral Collaboration. Presented at Trilateral Safety and Mission Assurance Conference (TRISMAC), June 4-6, 2018, Kennedy Space Center, Florida.
  • Campbell Leckey, C. A.; Juarez, P. D.; Hernando Quintanilla, F.; and Yu, L.: Lessons from Ultrasonic NDE Model Development. Presented at 26th ASNT Research Symposium 2017, March 13-16, 2017, Jacksonville, Florida.
  • Campbell Leckey, C. A.: Material State Awareness: Options to Address Challenges with UT. Presented at World Federation of NDE Centers Short Course 2017, July 15-16, 2017, Provo, Utah.
  • Campbell Leckey, C. A.; Hernando Quintanilla, F.; and Cole, C.: Numerically Stable Finite Difference Simulation for Ultrasonic NDE in Anisotropic Composites. Presented at 44th Annual Review of Progress in Quantitative Nondestructive Evaluation, July 16-21, 2017, Provo, Utah.
  • Cramer, K. E.; and Klaassen, R.: Developments in Advanced Inspection Methods for Composites Under the NASA Advanced Composites Project. Presented at GE Monthly Seminar Series, April 13, 2017, Cincinnati, Ohio.
  • Cramer, K. E.; and Perey, D. F.: Development and Validation of NDE Standards for NASA's Advanced Composites Project. Presented at ASNT Annual Conference, October 30-November 2, 2017, Nashville, Tennessee.
  • Cramer, K. E.: Current and Future Needs and Research for Composite Materials NDE. Presented at SPIE Smart Structures and NDE 2018, March 4-8, 2018, Denver, Colorado.
  • Cramer, K. E.: Research Developments in Non-Invasive Measurement Systems for Aerospace Composite Structures at NASA. Presented at 2018 International Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference, May 14-18, 2018, Houston, Texas.
  • Dehaven, S. L.; Wincheski, R. A.; and Burke, E. R.: X-ray Transmission Through Microstructured Optical Fiber. Presented at QNDE - Review of Progress in Quantitative NDE, July 17-21, 2017, Provo, Utah.
  • Dehaven, S. L.; Wincheski, R. A.; and Burke, E. R.: X-ray Transmission Through Microstructured Optical Fiber. Presented at 45th Annual Review of Progress in Quantitative Nondestructive Evaluation (QNDE), July 15-19, 2018, Burlington, Vermont.
  • Frankforter, E.; Campbell Leckey, C. A.; and Schneck, W. C.: Finite Difference Simulation of Ultrasonic Waves for Complex Composite Laminates. Presented at QNDE 2018, July 15-19, 2018, Burlington, Vermont.
  • Gregory, E. D.; and Juarez, P. D.: In-situ Thermography of Automated Fiber Placement Parts: Review of Progress in Quantitative Nondestructive Evaluation. Presented at QNDE - Review of Progress in Quantitative NDE, July 17-21, 2017, Provo, Utah.
  • Gregory, E. D.; Campbell Leckey, C. A.; Schneck, W. C.; Swindell, P: A Versatile Simulation Framework for Elastodynamic Modeling of Structural Health Monitoring; https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20190001865.

US Flag An Official Website of the United States Government